124 Comments

The answer is NO . Try reading the works of Peter Breggin ( on stack) and watch the four corners episode S 2023 ep 31. All eye opening. Then I found out on one stack the drugs come with a black box warning ‼️ n the US and 70% of school shooters are on SSRI ‘s and or SNRI’s. Also a lot of meds for anxiety like Xanax and the benzodiazepines are highly addictive- if you don’t keep increasing the dose the panic attacks escalate. I found that out through personal experience. With Xanax at the time (80) I couldn’t get doctors to believe me. I ended up shaving the pills down with a razor, and it was as bad as withdrawing from heroin. Cramping gut parts n sweats nausea vomiting the whole deal. The other thing, if you gain weight while taking this stuff it stores in fat, and every couple of kilos you loose the withdrawals come back ( also personal experience)

Expand full comment

Fascinating about the fat storage and withdrawals with weight loss, never heard of that before.

Expand full comment

Crikey Rebekah, what an awful experience.

I wonder what might have happened if a doctor had prescribed Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) for you in the first place, rather than put you on medication?

You say “neither of the two doctors who prescribed me these drugs warned me about how difficult they can be to withdraw from. I wasn’t properly informed about potential side effects either”.

This is the big problem, these ‘doctors’ often have no idea what they’re doing, prescribing medicines and vaccines like sweets, they’re often not authentically qualified to obtain informed consent.

General practitioners…what are these people doing prescribing anti-depressants?! How much damage are they causing in the community?

And now they want to flog antidepressants over the counter, with not even any pretence about people being informed about these products.

The entire situation is INSANE!

Aren’t other people seeing yet that the medical industrial complex has gone batshit crazy, with no curbs on the pHarmaceutical industry, with so-called ‘regulation’ (the TGA) actually funded by industry, aka the foxes in charge of the chicken coop.

The diabolical Covid scam should be bringing this into high relief now, with the community deliberately terrorised about a disease it was known from the beginning wasn’t a serious threat to most people.

We have to rise up against this travesty, pursue the actual people accountable for the gross over-medicalisation of society with never-ending testing, medicines and vaccines, coupled with the impact of misinformation, pressure, coercion and manipulation.

The public health terrorism being played out in our society is the very antithesis of health.

Expand full comment

What a nightmare you’ve been put through! I made 4 attempts before I came off steroids. With the medical profession I finally adopted the approach “you don’t live in my body, I do, so how can you know what’s right for me? “ I started to experiment with dosages…one 10mg tablet daily, or would 5mg do it, or a 5mg every 2 days? The worst experience was when my rheumatoid specialist changed the steroids to a new drug I later learned was a malarial drug. I told the 2 tablet prescribed dose and immediately my eyesight went. I stopped immediately but it took 10 days for the drug to clear my system. I later looked up the drug in a medical lexicon, and lo and behold one of the potential side effects was blindness! When I told him months later he blithely said “you should have stopped taking item”. Yeah right. It’s not his body so let’s experiment. I no longer trust doctors with anything. You have to monitor your own body. Doctors on the whole are simply taking a shot in the dark.

Expand full comment

Hi Rahima, I learned through this experience and some others that GPs are often making educated guesses, often with less education than we realise, and with time constraints (you can't cover much ground in a 15 min appointment). I had a similar thought process to you. Once I realised how much guess work was involved, and that I was the one experiencing the results, I started tuning in much more closely to my body and tinkering. I now think of my (functional medicine) doctor as a resource and trusted guide, but I have taken back responsibility for the final decisions myself. It helps that my current doctor offers much longer appointment times and way more thorough testing, although I pay for it.

Expand full comment

I was on prednisone and then Fosomax Plus for a side effect of the steroid. After about 9 months I just weaned off and stopped. Never again will I trust a doctor.

Expand full comment

Rahima, did your doctor or you report your experience of an adverse event with your eyesight after medication to the TGA?

Also see my response to Christine for more info.

It’s highly alarming that there is not effective post-marketing surveillance of all medications and drugs.

If adverse events aren’t reported we aren’t going to have accurate data on the effectiveness and safety of these products.

Expand full comment

I agree. But this was some years back and reporting and the TGA’s profile was not in the public mindset the way it is today.

Expand full comment

Gives one to think then…about all the adverse events that haven’t been reported…

Expand full comment

What about Sabril - an anticonvulsant that can result in loss of visual field in a high percentage of patients (very nasty as most people are unaware of visual field defects until it approaches central fixation point)

Expand full comment

Definitely a NO from me too.

I was put on them as a child of 8... (I look back on this with disgust at the 'medical professionals' who thought this was a good idea. I don't blame my family as they love me and were doing what they were advised to by the 'experts' and all they wanted was for me to be healthy and happy). I have been on anti-depressants for decades now.

Because of the events of the last 4 years, I have made a decison to try alternative therapies for my depression and anxiety. I have found a psychiatrist to help me safely taper off the drugs, as well as seeing a naturopath and a social worker. I am looking at my diet, exercising, spending time appreciating God's creation, and above all, praying to the God who loves me and wants me to have an 'abudant' life.

I am now on a dosage that is 1/4 of what I was on last year. So far, so good.

Praying for all those in the same situation as me.

Expand full comment

Wow that is so young to start.

Expand full comment

Try going to the Breggin Substack they recently posted a video called manufacturing madness- a Gary Null production on Rumble. I’m an ex nurse was married to a psychiatrist, and so much of that vid rings true.

Expand full comment

If there was an honest Doctor in the world they would book everyone straight into a CBT course, send them on a nutritional medicine course, provide a personal trainer and gym membership. Instead they get a nice backhander to ply everyone with dangerous and ineffective pills. Revolting.

Expand full comment

Adding physios - completely non-invasive - getting the body basically straight does wonders for general health - I think the electrical signalling/ bloodflow/everything goes a lot better.

Expand full comment

My 40 year journey through medicine has involved 15 years in general practice before retraining in sports and exercise medicine, an area in which I have practiced for the last 18 years.

Part of my reason for changing disciplines is the growing adherence of mainstream medicine to pharmaceutical/ surgical paths for virtually all conditions (obesity, mental health, diabetes, heart disease, etc).

Sports and exercise medicine involves lifestyle assessment first with very few prescriptions, and even minimally invasive procedures often involve non-pharmaceutical regimes, such as autologous blood products.

I now also take between 30 and 60 minutes for each consultation, which enables a full social, diet and activity/ exercise assessment, and treatment emphasizes lifestyle improvements.

I find this kind of practice to be much more fulfilling and beneficial to both patients and myself.

Accordingly, I do not feel antidepressants should be available OTC.

Expand full comment

Love this!

Expand full comment

I gradually tapered off SSRIs for 18/12 and stopped at Xmas 2023. Even though I had reduced the dose right down, the effects of withdrawal was not fun. Certainly nothing like your experiences though but still feelings of dissociation and of being very unstable mentally. I rode it out and now seem to be ok. Certainly scary stuff and there is no way it should be over the counter.

Expand full comment

Yeah you had it rough. I came off them hard too. First time I failed and ended up in a psyche ward. The brain snaps are the most weird thing and floods of anxiety are horrific. Second time I stepped them down - Broke the pills up and reduced the dosage by about 10% per week until I was free of them. It worked. Horrible bloody things.

Expand full comment

What a journey. Well done 👏🏼

Expand full comment

Yes I found out about the fat issue from a Dutch production late 80’s broadcast on SBS I think. I also found out that the receptors in the brain for anti depressants also share receptors for narcotics and synthetic narcotics. I discovered that one by accident when I was prescribed a synthetic narcotic when still on a maintenance dose of antidepressants. Violent reaction - crushing headache, projectile vomiting. I should disclose I’m an ex nurse, was married to a psychiatrist, and I’m under no illusions about big pharma employing “ inflluncers” I’ve seen that first hand. That 4 corners episode has psychiatrists exposing it . They are from a highly respected psych institution called Maudsley in the UK.

Expand full comment

Re the receptor thing, I believe this is why Naltrexone can help people get off SSRIs and other potent anti-depressants, in the same manner that it does for narcotics.

Re the fat thing, fat stores are a kind of safe warehousing area. When there is anything circulating in the body that is in excess of what the body can use or process, it gets shuffled into fat stores (to be safely stored with lipid and water). This includes toxic byproducts of things we consume, but also excess hormones like cortisol, noradrenaline, estrogen etc...

This is part of the reason very overweight people can struggle to get the weight off — they feel really grim, emotionally unbalanced, stressed / depressed etc when they diet (especially when they fast), and if they don't understand what's happening they may not have the motivation to push through. What's happening is that they're creating an energy deficit, and as a consequence the fat stores are opened up and all the hormones and stored crap gets dumped into the system, bringing on headaches, nausea, jitters, mood imbalances — all kinds of symptoms of the uptick in circulating toxins and hormonal overload. This is something that the public could be a lot better educated on, for sure.

Expand full comment

When I was studying for a B.Ed. in 1968, a pharmacy lecturer came to talk about how to recognise when students were on drugs. One item I always remember is that the active ingredient in marijuana gets stored in the fat cells of the body; and if the user discontinues, flash-backs can still occur.

Expand full comment

That's really interesting.

Expand full comment

In the early 80’s I was prescribed Xanax - was told it was not addictive. I used to have panic attacks. Worked for some time, however not long n reason ng the dose I started to have panic attacks again. I tried to get help, but the drug promos and the influences meant I couldn’t get help. I did my own withdrawal- worse than coming home ff heroin. Cold sweats nausea cramps nausea etc. I also went for n a fitness and weight management regime. Every 2-3 kilos I lost went through withdrawals again. That s when I came across the Dutch research regarding benzodiazepines being stored in fat. After what I went through it made sense.

Expand full comment

All makes sense. I’ve read a number of studies relating to serotonin and dopamine where people without depression were compared to people on the antidepressants for said deficits- turns out non depressed people had similar or lower readings on both substances. The other issue is psychiatrists appear to forget about physical illness that can present as mental health issues. I’ve come across two people treated for psychosis who had thyroid tumors. Problem eventually discovered and treated, but not before significant harm. And another who had a congenital brain malformation who was turned into a dribbling mess with psych meds. Treated she became a whole different woman.

Expand full comment

I've been aware of that. Four days into eating less food I'd start to get headaches - was sure I was releasing toxins, etc.

Expand full comment

Crikey it’s shocking how much damage these drugs are causing!

As I’ve noted in previous responses to others, there’s little in the way of post-marketing surveillance re effectiveness and safety.

Nobody wants to know it seems…least of all Big pHarma, the ‘regulator’, or the prescribing doctor…

Expand full comment

QUOTE

Australia is the second highest user of antidepressants per capita (around one in 10 adults) among Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries excluding the USA.2 In the year to June 2020, for the first time an antidepressant (sertraline) was in the top 10 Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme/Repatriation Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme medications by defined daily dose/1000 population/day.3 Evidence suggests long-term use (>12 months), rather than new diagnoses, is driving the increase.4–6 GPs prescribe most antidepressants in Australia (86.3%).7

Often, antidepressant prescribing is not consistent with clinical guidance. According to the most recent Bettering the Evaluation and Care of Health (BEACH) survey data, 12.4% of general practice encounters are mental health–related, and most of these encounters are managed with medication (61.6%).7 Clinical guidelines recommend psychological therapies for mild depression and anxiety, and 6–12 months of antidepressant therapy for a single episode of moderate-to-severe depression.8,9 Yet in Australia the average duration of therapy is now approximately four years,4 and half of users are long-term users.5 There is also concerning variation in antidepressant prescribing, with rates higher for people in lower socioeconomic or inner regional areas and nearly double in older (≥65 years) when compared with younger people.10 Nearly one in three older Australians admitted to residential care in 2008–15 was taking antidepressants on admission, and this only increased after admission.11

There remains ongoing debate about what constitutes appropriate prescribing, but every GP knows that antidepressants cannot treat common social issues such as grief, loneliness, unemployment or poverty. There is general agreement that antidepressants are no more effective than medication placebo in less severe depressive disorders,12 and there remain questions regarding whether antidepressants have any useful effects against more severe depression over and above the placebo effect.13 It has never been substantiated that antidepressants reverse an underlying chemical (serotonin) deficiency or other brain abnormality, yet they modify the brain in ways that are not fully understood, with potentially harmful consequences.14–16

END OF QUOTE

Recommend reading the entire article, see: RACGP - Antidepressant prescribing in general practice: https://www1.racgp.org.au/ajgp/2021/december/antidepressant-prescribing-in-general-practice

Expand full comment

Goodness, a lot of antidepressant use for such a lucky country.

Expand full comment

So what is motivating GPs to prescribe anti-depressants I wonder?

Are anti-depressant manufacturers ‘educating’ GPs in this area?

Something to look into, after the startling revelation that the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners is in bed with the vaccine industry-funded Immunisation Coalition, accrediting that organisation to provide ‘continuing professional development’ (CPD), aka promoting vaccine products to doctors, the frontline sales/police force for vaccine products in the community. See: The vaccine industry sponsors vaccination education for doctors... https://elizabethhart.substack.com/p/the-vaccine-industry-sponsors-vaccination

Expand full comment

No way over the counter! I think GPs shouldn’t be able to prescribe either.

Expand full comment

We have a huge issue with the under-training bordering on blind ignorance of doctors. I have recently had a high blood pressure crisis to go with everything else I am dealing with, and my normal herbal recourse simply did not work. I am happy if I am in the 140's over something under 100 but my doctor had written me a script for high blood pressure medication to treat that, that I had refused to fill or take. But then it exploded to between 180-200 over around 100, which is getting pretty serious. So he wrote me another script for a different medication which i filled and conceded that I had to take - at least short term while we investigate the cause. I proceeded to have the reaction that I have to almost all drugs and cheaper nutraceuticals, I got serious pain and neuropathy in my legs that stopped me from sleeping. Which of course, is just going to make my blood pressure worse. The doctor simply told me that pain in the legs was not a side effect of the drug I was on and refused to even address the leg pain issue.

Realising that I needed to keep taking it while we investigate WHY it had skyrocketed, I wondered if it might be the fillers that I was reacting to, so I rang a dispensing chemist to see if they could make them up with no neurotoxins in the fillers. I gave the names of both medications that the doctor had prescribed at different times. The chemist came back to me with an impossible price, but also with information on both medications. One has side effects of leg cramps, the other has side effects of leg pain and neuropathy, which means it might be the drug itself and not the fillers I am reacting to. That has left me with no solution, and no way to talk to the doctor in question because HE EITHER DOESN'T KNOW OR HE HAS LIED to me, and neither is a good look.

While doctors are little more than drug pushers with no real understanding of the drugs they are pushing, and while they do not even bother to read the inserts for themselves, let alone address the issues posed by just how dangerous even the most commonly used drugs are, we have little choice but to do our own research and self-medicate where we can.

During my crisis, the chemist who dispensed the nitro-glycerine that the same doctor ordered for me to use in a crisis, asked me how I was using it and I told him the doctors instructions. He looked very concerned and told me "that is not the way you use this drug". But he had not choice but to dispense it, frowning all the way. Then on my doctors instructions, when my blood pressure went over 190/100 at home, I called the ambulance. The paramedic also saw the nitro and said "you haven't taken that have you?". To which i answered yes, on doctors instructions, and he explained that the nitro will take the BP down into a safer zone but only very briefly after which the body will rebound to a higher BP than it was administered at. Oh goody. Fortunately he was willing to hang around for long enough to watch it go well over 200 in the rebound, and stayed with me until it had dropped again to 180 over something. HE also recommended I did not go to hospital because the beds were all full so i would be left sitting in casualty for hour, which would also cause my BP, and may be my brain, to explode. His recommendation, lie down and watch TV. It turns out there is nothing much we can do when we have a BP crisis like the one I was (and maybe still am) having.

So here we have a paramedic AND and two different chemists, giving advice contrary to the advice given by my doctor. So maybe we would be better buying our drugs over the counter, from a qualified chemist, or a paramedic, rather than trusting a doctor.

Expand full comment

Re: “The doctor simply told me that pain in the legs was not a side effect of the drug I was on and refused to even address the leg pain issue.”

If you’ve had an adverse event after a medication this should be reported to the TGA.

I suspect this very seldom happens…because it’s more work for the doctor, and implicates him/her if he prescribed it for you.

People can also make their own report, but not a lot of people know this… See: https://aems.tga.gov.au

See also this web page on the TGA website, which I suggest is window dressing… https://www.tga.gov.au/resources/resource/guidance/reporting-adverse-events#gpsoftware

Unfortunately the highly conflicted TGA, which is funded by industry, can’t be trusted to review adverse event reports objectively.

We really have no idea of what adverse events the massive range of medications might be causing, because only lip service is paid to post-marketing surveillance.

This is another serious problem in the medical industrial complex that must be addressed.

Expand full comment

No - even though we are all guinea pigs when it comes to drugs - the doctors still need to be in charge of that prescription for anti-depressants & let them know of any adverse events. I tried about 6-7 different classes of SSRI's SNRI's and I experienced intolerable side effects with all of them (over a period of 20 years) The last one was prescribed by my oncologist (Effexor) for menopausal symptoms/night sweats/sleepdisorder etc. This drug was a diaster in every way - my therapist mentioned this drug should be withdrawn. I am now off ALL drugs and have found Vitamin D & exercise to be a a successful solution. It has calmed me down and allowed me to function as normally as possible.

Expand full comment

A friend of mine going through a divorce part of the Court order was to take her child (6 years) to a psychiatrist. He prescribed anti-depressants fortunately Mum had the foresight to buy some lollies that looked similar to the medication and gave him one every night telling him it was his ‘antidepressant’ to make him better. This happened for 3 months until the psychiatrist brought my friend into the room saying ‘look how much better he is’. ‘I was right to put him on medication’!!!! They should be banned. My partner got off them with mindfulness and exercise. Although knowing what we do now I would have used homeopathy. It is very successful in mental cases and was the main medical system used in early 1900’s. There is a great book ‘Sane Asylum….the success of homeopathy before psychiatry lost its mind’. Very safe as well.

Expand full comment

WOW! This post couldn't be any more timely. I just saw a PCP last week about tapering off the antidepressant I've been on for about ten years. He seemed so nonchalant about it. I asked him if he knew of any pharmacies that offered titration of medications so I could come off of it really slowly, since I'd had horrible withdrawals from other antidepressants I've taken over the decades (yes, decades!) He dismissed me by saying tapering the doses with what was available should be fine. So, I've been trying to find a pharmacy on my own that might be able to provide that service. If anyone knows of such a thing in California, I would love hearing back from you as that is where I live. Thank you and much luck to others who find themselves in this horrendous pharmaceutical-built boat.

Expand full comment

Go to survivingantidepressants dot org for tapering protocols and information.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much! 💕

Expand full comment

Of course, legal disclaimer - your health is your responsibility, I cannot be blamed etc.

Good luck.

Expand full comment

Absolutely! If anyone half way aware over the past four years doesn't understand this, they are hopeless.

Expand full comment

This resonated with me in so many ways. Thank you for sharing your story. And no way should they be over the counter. I personally don’t believe they work besides the potential placebo effect.

Expand full comment