27 Comments

thank you Rebekah,

your readers should know this story is far from over

more later

Expand full comment
Mar 1Liked by Rebekah Barnett

To say Dr Fidge is not an aggrieved person is straight up gaslighting.

Australia, you have truly fallen.

Expand full comment
Mar 1·edited Mar 1Liked by Rebekah Barnett

A quick google search of the judge finds this...

Justice Rofe was called to the Bar in 2001, taking silk in 2014. At the Bar, she specialised in science and technology related matters. She has significant experience in representing clients in the pharmaceutical, agricultural, mining, and manufacturing industries......

Expand full comment
Mar 1Liked by Rebekah Barnett

Thanks Rebekah. It is looking increasingly clear that there are strong forces that do not want these kinds of questions to be discussed and evidence to be publicised, and will cling to any possible mechanism to prevent it from happening.

Is that really how the law is supposed to work?

Expand full comment
founding

Another incredibly disheartening outcome this morning. Yet, I still believe the determination of Katie, Julian, Peter, Julian, other applicants, AVN, Rebekah, and the thousands of us who refuse to let the egregious policy failures (to put it mildly) of the last few years stand, will ultimately prevail.

Expand full comment
Mar 1Liked by Rebekah Barnett

Stooges everywhere - do not presume the law is about justice. That concept is as archaic as notions of bodily autonomy and informed consent. Consent is a manufacture based on legal fictions, enforced by the state through its courts in service of mammon and the almighty (dollar that is). The minor cases that provided solace to the few who won their initial stoush with authority over the past couple of weeks, have now to be put into perspective; and the perspective has a microscope in front of it displaying that dystopic world of SynthBio. Be thankful that their constructs bear the inevitable mark of self-destruction; and that we can see it. So get out your dancing shoes!

Expand full comment
Mar 1Liked by Rebekah Barnett

To get a little bit of a feel for how Justice Rofe perceives the workings of Australian society in general, it is worthwhile reading the transcript of her address to the assembled members of the Australian Federal Court on the 06 May 2022 when she was first appointed. The transcript can be found via the following link:

https://www.fedcourt.gov.au/digital-law-library/judges-speeches/justice-rofe/justice-rofe

Expand full comment
Mar 1Liked by Rebekah Barnett

Once again, the road block on "standing."

Expand full comment
Mar 3Liked by Rebekah Barnett

I wonder if Dr Fitch's appeal would entail item 1 on the Dealings list - conduct an experiment with GMO's? Seems logical that this would be his standing...

Expand full comment
founding

I just went to the Federal Court of Australia YouTube channel to look at the video of today's finding again, as I am interested in how many views it has had, but I can no longer find it on there. Has is been removed, or am I just technologically challenged?

Expand full comment